
I don’t want Doug Gillin to hire the next App State Football coach.
Those are my feelings after the Mountaineers lost easily to Georgia State at home. In eight days, the inside road to the Sun Belt Championship Game opened up by the JMU win fell apart. Any shred of goodwill is gone.
I could stop writing now, but there’s a lot that’s happened since right after the Old Dominion game.
If you feel I’m just compelled to write after cataclysmic losses, you might be correct.
I’ve wanted to write since then and started multiple times. But the overwhelming nature of being thrown right back into realignment pandemonium, the parking lot disaster and the overall vibes of everything stopped me each time. That’s an excuse, but it’s also the truth.
The Old Dominion game mentally broke a lot of fans, myself included. It ruined what was shaping up to be a really good season, exposing an NFL Man as not having the answers to score even one touchdown in a hurricane.
Then, before the coffee hit the next Monday morning, the shockwave came. JMU was going to the American Conference. The upstart purple team, which five years ago traveled to New Hampshire for conference games, collected the $28 million needed to jump ship.
It’s an open secret that App State has talked to the American Conference for years. They’ve talked to a lot of teams, but App State was a constant.
Regardless of what Sun Belt fans feel, the American has a higher floor and, most times, a higher ceiling.
The ambition of JMU and what seemed to be a lack of ambition by App State is what irks and confuses so many.
And the lack of ambition toward what matters is laser-focused on App State AD Doug Gillin.
Dollar Doug cares about the money more than anything else, or so it seems. It’s all he talks about. Gotta raise money, gotta get the budget to $100 million by 2030, gotta #DonateTheScore, gotta hold these fundraising events for the same people. By several accounts, Doug has gotten colder, and for someone who already has a list of enemies, his list is a mile long.
With Gillin, it feels like the last couple of years with Everts. You know it’s coming, but you don’t know when. What will the last paper cut be? Will he get pushback on his precious East Tower? Gillin wants this East Tower bad. He wants it to complete his legacy, using the guise of there being too many people wanting premium suites and not enough spaces for them.
App State is more than one man or a group of donors that have at least one comma in their yearly donation, more than Tommy Sofield or those in the parking lots around the stadium. But does Doug Gillin know this? It seems not. While JMU was writing to the American Conference to formally request membership, App State was writing to its most loyal donors to fleece them.

The above landed in mailboxes a day or two after the JMU/American news. Even if ODU was a massive win and vibes were high, this was a bomb dropped on the fanbase. A bomb that shouldn’t have been dropped.
The reasoning for these lot minimum hikes is sound. There are waiting lists for the lower-dollar lots, costs are going up and the lot minimums have been the same for years. It sucks, but a department that communicated these ideas for months in open meetings to donors and alums and let people know over a year in advance while offering alternate ideas would probably get these through with little issue.
But nope, it’s in the mail next to the power bill that went up this year, the water bill that just increased and probably multiple annoying political fliers.
The Group of Six fanbase that pays the highest season ticket prices, $5 for a 20 oz Pepsi and $2 for a cup with ice, travelling up a mountain to games, staying in $250+ a night hotels with two- or three-night minimums, seeing Bojangles jack up prices 35% on game days with limited menus, who deals with constant change in security stations to enter the game, now has to pony up more to park where many have parked for years. And with two months’ notice before 2027, when payment plans are made.
It’s admitted that the unveiling was a disaster. Now staffers are having webinars? Is anything changing? Doesn’t appear so. Can you participate live? No, you must submit questions in a Google Form ahead of time. Basically, they don’t want to be yelled at.
Doug Gillin has heard you. He mentioned it during the Coastal pre-game show. He used the same language being used elsewhere. App State HAS to do this.
No, you don’t. And after the last two games, and no, you shouldn’t.
Selling out games and having waiting lists for VIP suites and parking lots has been a Gillin staple of his speeches. Yes, they look good. And it’s rare to have full stadiums in This Modern Landscape of College Football.
But from what I’ve seen. it’s hard to lose a fanbase, but once it’s lost, it’s very hard to get it back. Look at 2014-2017 attendance in home games not featuring ACC teams. Took an entire college tenure to turn the corner and get fans back after Jerry, 2013, and all that.
I feel App State is in danger of this happening again. Oh, I’m sorry, it’s APPSTATE. Usually in a font, as seen in the mailer above, that resembles a cross between Subway and NASCAR.
That’s Doug Gillin’s doing. Years ago, it was Appalachian. Then Appalachian State. Then Gillin, who is a branding guy, brought in the APPSTATE brand.
I hate it, have always hated it, and continue to hate it. APPSTATE feels like surrendering the identity, especially pronouncing the school’s full name. “ap-puh-LATCH-an” should be a constant fight.
But just like the black Block A being forced on every 50-yard line, half court, center circle, tennis court and ball field, Gillin flies the APPSTATE flag.
Between being surpassed by JMU, the parking wars, being a cold and distant AD, always bringing up money, saying “App State has to help App State,” desperately wanting to plunge APPSTATE into way more debt to build an East Tower, being a terrible concert promoter and hiring an NFL Man who doesn’t care about what happened at APPSTATE before December 2024 and can’t admit who’s calling the offensive plays, the Gillin Era needs to end. It’s been over a decade. His last great idea was hiring Dustin Kerns in 2019 and his 2015-2019 was excellent. That was almost eight years ago. This era is stale, stagnant, morale is low, funding is in trouble and honestly, do you want him hiring the next football coach? He’d probably hire Jon Pardi and Niko Moon to call plays.
Leave a Reply