marshall postmortem – run forever?

Never discount an App State win in Huntington. No matter what you feel about the head coach and how much they say the defense has trouble tackling.

Was it lucky? Possibly. Something forced those fumbles, someone turned on the strobe lights thinking it was a touchdown, and someone made those stops short of a first down late in the game.

Given the circumstances, the team stepped up to win on the road at a rival. That should always warrant a celebration.

The Sun Belt East portion of the schedule ends 3-3, and what a weird 3-3 it was. Losing at home to Old Dominion and Georgia State, while winning at Coastal and Marshall. Then beating JMU when they had the inside track to not only the conference title but the CFB Playoff. Losing at Georgia Southern sucks, but was probably the least surprising result of the six.

The common theme among fans is concern about the running game. The run game didn’t exist earlier in the season, which was baffling. In a hurricane, App State kept on throwing the ball. Even though the run game averaged 3.4 yards per carry.

Dowell found himself committing the Run and Shoot sins of the past. You throw yourself out of drives, the defense is on the field longer and eventually they break. At Georgia Southern, there were six rushing attempts, which seemed like a sin against Appalachian State Football.
At Marshall, the lessons were learned early. 3rd and 2, throwing the ball, Marshall was ready and jumped the route for an interception. Later, on 3rd and 2, an option pitch to the outside; the pitch is behind the RB and Marshall recovers.

During all this, the runs between the tackles looked to be there. But then throwing the ball usually ended the drives. To Dowell’s credit, he has shown an ability to adjust at halftime, and the offense adjusted. The game plan became simplified: run forever.

It could have been a multi-score win, but given where this team has been, winning in the fourth quarter will do. It took overcoming a bad fumble and a pair of fourth-down stops, but the team crossed the finish line.

Now, with two games left, this is the second-best App State team of the last five seasons. Boy, that’s weird to write out. But it doesn’t feel like it. Why?

Well, because Dowell is in that territory where the losses stung so much. Given the promise the team showed at NC State, versus JMU and, to a degree, at ECU, plus his constant blaming of the defense in press conferences and the whole “he’s not an App State guy” thing some will always hold against him, a Dowell 4-loss team feels worse than a Clark 6-loss team.

Some App State fans are in an alternate reality where they still think it’s 1997 and the little ol Mountaineers can’t financially compete, and everyone else just has so much more money. This is nonsense.
In the Sun Belt, App State dwarfs everyone else in ticket sales and merch. Corporate dollars probably aren’t there (especially looking at JMU), but continually crying poor to the same donors will cause people to go from angry to apathetic. Angry people can be brought back. If they go apathetic, you lose them for a generation. You already have graduating classes who have seen .500 football their entire college career. Not the players, but the students. The ones who might come back, sleep on a friend’s floor, then get married, have kids, and not come back for a few years, but eventually will want to. I saw it with my friends and with those slightly younger than me.

Coaches and administrators will always claim We. Don’t. Have. Enough. Money. That’s why they can’t accomplish all the fans’ dreams. If you would stop being so frugal and Donate. To. The. Yosef. Club. then there would be an ice cream in every child’s hand, the QB would never be sacked, the defense would never allow a point and Georgia Southern would lose every game.

I get what Dowell is trying to do. And I get the limitations he feels. One of those will be rectified this offseason. Recruiting is better. The team is modernizing. Dowell is learning. But can the team take the next step?
And please, for the love of everything, don’t lose at home to ULM, or everything written above is meaningless.

Leave a Reply